Rosalyn Sphinx has been trying to get pregnant by fucking her stepdad. She invites her two BFFs Madison Summers and Maya Woulfe over to see the results of her latest pregnancy test as a trio. When it comes back negative, Maya suggests that Rosalyn try her stepbrother, Jay Romero, instead. Maya even offers that she and Madison will come along to help get all Jay's cum out. Fortunately for them, Jay comes out just then to see what all the commotion is about. That's the perfect moment for the three girls to put their plan into action.

Cornering Jay, the girls inform him that he's going to give Rosalyn all his cum. They push him down onto the couch, inform him that it's not a game, and encourage him to kiss his stepsister. Next, Jay is told to touch Rosalyn's boobs. Rosalyn confesses she's already wet as she encourages Jay to find out for himself. That's when Madison and Maya move in to make it clear this is a foursome, not a twosome. Taking Jay's hand, the girls guide him to the bedroom and throw him down onto the bed to have their naughty way with him.

They peel off Jay's pants so they can share his cock in a triple blowjob that gets him nice and hard. Maya leads the way with the sex, swinging her leg over Jay's thighs and riding him in cowgirl as Madison settles onto Jay's face to ride his tongue. Madison gets the next cowgirl ride with her BFFs squeezing her ass and fondling her titties. When Rosalyn goes for a ride, Jay gives it to her but can't quite give her his cum yet. Maya has an idea to milk the jizz from Jay. She instructs Madison to lay down and Rosalyn to get on her knees on top of Madison. Jay gives both girls some due diligence with his tongue, then indulges in the double pussy stack. When Jay finally gives Rosalyn the creampie the girls have been waiting for, Maya uses her fingers to take some cum deposit into Madison's pussy and then her own so that perhaps all three of them might get pregnant at once.